The Guide to Anal Plugs

Why Are Anal Plugs So Controversial—Yet So Tempting?

If there were a vote for the most controversial sex toy of all time, anal plugs would definitely make the list.

They have no gender restrictions, yet they can unlock very different pleasure zones for different bodies:

For men, anal plugs can open the door to prostate orgasms
For women, wearing an anal plug can make the vaginal canal feel tighter, amplifying penetration pleasure and creating more layered orgasms

That’s why opinions about anal plugs are often completely polarized.

One group becomes instant fans—every time they use an anal plug, it feels like unlocking a hidden level in a game. The moment it slides in, the internal monologue is basically:
“Oh… so this is the legendary door to a whole new world.”

The other group hears the word “anal” and instantly clenches up, thinking:
“No thanks. My life doesn’t need to be that adventurous.”

But here’s the thing: if anal plugs have stayed popular for so long—and if search terms like “how to use an anal plug” and “best anal plug” keep climbing year after year—then they’re clearly not just a niche curiosity.

Existence is proof.
Anal plugs aren’t just for “extreme” players. For many people, they’re a tool for discovering entirely new types of pleasure.

Honestly, I (the editor) used to be firmly in the “hard pass” camp too. The first time I saw an anal plug, my reaction was:
“That looks… like a bit much.”

But after actually learning about how anal plugs work—their anatomy, size choices, lubrication rules, and safety principles—I realized something important:

What I feared wasn’t the anal plug itself.
It was all the labels and stereotypes society, porn, and memes attach to “anal play.”

Once you put those aside and actually understand what an anal plug is, how to choose the right one, and how to use it safely, it stops being scary.

Instead, it becomes a calm, patient guide—gently leading you to sensations you might never have noticed before. You may even find yourself thinking:

“Turns out I don’t dislike anal plugs.
I just disliked anal plugs that no one ever taught me how to use.”

That’s why this article exists.
We’ll break down everything about anal plugs:

Why are they so popular?
How do you choose the right one without regretting it?
Does it hurt the first time?
How do you use one safely and enjoyably?

After reading, you don’t have to rush to add an anal plug to your cart.
But you will be able to confidently say:
“I understand anal plugs now. Want to explore them together?” 😉

How Anal Plugs Create Pleasure

Why One Plug Can Change Everything

Many people assume anal plugs are only for hardcore players. In reality, they’re a pleasure tool for all genders—just for very different reasons.

For Men: Anal Plugs = The Key to the Prostate

For men, the biggest appeal of anal plugs is their proximity to the prostate (the legendary P-spot).

This area has an incredibly high density of nerve endings. With the right pressure—or vibration—it can trigger a type of orgasm that feels completely different from ejaculation.

Many men describe it like this:
“A prostate orgasm isn’t just stronger—it’s an entirely different species of pleasure.”

For Women: Tighter Sensation, Deeper Orgasms

Women don’t have a prostate, but that doesn’t mean anal play is sensation-free.

The anal opening is packed with nerve endings, making even light stimulation noticeable. Once an anal plug is in place, it gently presses against the back wall of the vagina, which can:

Make penetration feel tighter
Increase friction
Turn orgasms into a more three-dimensional experience

Many women’s first reaction is:
“Wait… why does this make orgasms easier?”

Some even discover vaginal orgasms for the first time with an anal plug’s help, thinking:
“So I wasn’t ‘insensitive’—I just needed backup.”

Anal plugs aren’t just for “extreme” players.
They’re for anyone curious about unlocking new layers of pleasure.

How to Use an Anal Plug Without Pain

The two biggest fears for first-timers are:

“Will it hurt?”
“Is my butt actually ready for this?”

Totally understandable. The first time I tried an anal plug, I stood in the bathroom taking ten deep breaths, thinking:
“Please be gentle. I still want to sit comfortably later.”

What I learned is this:
When used correctly, anal plugs are far gentler than you expect.

Below is a beginner-friendly Anal Plug SOP, designed to keep your body relaxed and your mind at ease.

Before You Start: Essential Preparation

Before you even touch the plug, make sure you do these three things. They’re not optional—they’re the difference between discomfort and enjoyment.

1. Set Boundaries & Use a Safe Word

Never “surprise” someone from behind
Surprise ≠ sexy when it comes to anal play
No one should be caught mentally unprepared

The anus is extremely sensitive. Without consent and communication, even small actions can turn into lasting fear.

2. Cleaning & Relaxation

Use the bathroom first
If needed, rinse gently with warm water or use an anal cleanser

This isn’t just about hygiene—it greatly reduces anxiety and helps your body relax.

3. Use Plenty of Lubricant

This is non-negotiable.

The anus does not self-lubricate. Without enough lube, even the smallest, softest plug can feel unbearable.

Lubricant Pairing Guide

Silicone plug → Use water-based lubricant only
(Silicone lube can damage silicone toys)
Glass or metal plug → Water-based or silicone lube is fine

Best Positions for Beginners

Using an anal plug is not “aim and shove.”
Your body deserves patience.

Recommended Positions

All fours (doggy style): Naturally relaxes the anus, easiest to control
Side-lying with knees slightly bent: Most beginner-friendly
Self-use: Squatting or sitting on the toilet can reduce mental pressure

Choose a position where you feel safe, stable, and relaxed.

Step-by-Step Insertion Guide

Coat your finger with lubricant and gently circle the anal opening
Lightly press and tease to let the sphincter adapt
Apply lubricant generously to the tip of the plug
Slowly push, don’t jab
When you feel resistance, pause—inhale, then exhale as you move slightly deeper
Once the body of the plug is inside and the neck rests at the sphincter, you’ll feel a secure “locked-in” sensation

🚨 Stop immediately if you feel sharp pain, burning, or dizziness. Remove the plug slowly and reassess size or lubrication.

How Long Should You Wear an Anal Plug?